🗞️Opposition Leader Calls for Global Benchmark on Misinformation Penalties

To set an example for the rest of the world, the opposition leader says, harsher sanctions requiring social media companies to remove false content from their platforms should be implemented. As false theories and graphic content were uploaded to platforms in the wake of Monday's Bondi Junction attack and the stabbing at a Sydney church, Peter Dutton has supported calls for tougher penalties to combat misinformation online. The government's misinformation laws were postponed because of concerns about free speech, but the incidents have spurred a new push for them.

According to Mr. Dutton, the coalition was open to cooperating with the government on the proposal.

“Yeah, we are, and happy to have a look at anything the Government puts forward, as we've said over the last week, with the horrendous scenes that we've seen. There's obviously AI tools that are available, there's a lot of technology – because you're talking about at scale and people who get accounts closed down, pop up under another name and pseudonym, otherwise.

As Home Affairs Minister, we tried to get all of the Five Eyes partners together, the Home Affairs Ministers to exert pressure, particularly in relation to the child protection space.

These companies have snubbed their noses at Governments in the United States, Canada, Britain, New Zealand, Australia, for many, many years, the European Union I think has had a gut full as well. They're allowing paedophiles to distribute through their networks, images and videos of children being sexually abused, they're impeding the investigations of the police.

So, there are many aspects here that we need to deal with. Just given the impact, the influence that it has on young, impressionable minds, I think we need to do everything we can.” Mr. Dutton told the ABC's Insiders program on Sunday.

When Mr. Dutton questioned whether there was a case for taking more severe measures against social media companies?.

He said “ No question at all, and I think there's a bipartisan position in relation to this. We know that the companies – and we've seen some of the comments from Elon Musk overnight – they see themselves above the law. The Australian law here should apply equally in the real world as it does online. As Phil was pointing out before, you would be sued for defamation and you would be taken before the courts under various acts for publishing some of that which freely flows on the internet.

There's an age verification regime which has been recommended by the eSafety Commissioner from 2023. We think that's something the Government should pick up straightaway as well, but the Online Safety Act has significant powers in it, we passed it when we were in government and it needs to be enforced. If the laws are inadequate and they need to be strengthened or added to, then we would support any effort from the Government.

Nothing is free like a free press. Give now to help sustain independent journalism in your community.

It's evident from recent events that there has never been a better moment to support local news. Donate now to help sustain independent reporting.

Under the law, social media companies that fail to remove misleading content would face harsher penalties. The coalition worried the government's misinformation bill would stifle political debate and dissent, but Mr. Dutton said social media platforms needed a tougher stance.

“We need to get the right balance. So, that is we don't want to impinge on your ability to express a view in a democracy. It's a key, fundamental element of who we are, that people can express their view, but they need to do it respectfully, and as I say, the same laws need to apply in the real world as they do online. It's a matter of enforcing the laws and taking action, giving the eSafety Commissioner further powers if that's required. But I think here we're talking about images in particular, which are offensive and which can trigger violent reactions as we saw, earlier this week.” He said.

To recall, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said the companies had a social responsibility to stop the spread of the stabbing footage after a week filled with trauma and anger following the murders in Westfield Bondi Junction.

A journalist questioned Prime Minister Anthony Albanese about the possibility of stricter regulations for social media firms in the wake of the shocking vision that was clearly displayed over the weekend.

Mr. Albanese said , “ Well, we've taken strong action already. We quadrupled funding for the eSafety Commissioner. I say this, media companies, including social media companies, have a responsibility to act. It shouldn't need the eSafety Commissioner to intervene, to direct companies, in this case X and Meta, to take down violent videos that show people who have lost their lives as a result of what occurred with the perpetrator committing that atrocity on Saturday. The fact that that was circulated is something that had a real detrimental impact.”

“The Minister for Communications has directed those companies to take down that footage. I also make this point that the police made last Saturday, which is that for people who had video footage of last Saturday, their first thought should not have been to post it online. Their first thought should have been to forward it to police to assist their investigations. We all have, because social media makes all of us publishers of content, we all have a responsibility. But the social media companies that make a lot of money out of their business have a social responsibility. And I want to see social media companies start to understand their social responsibility that they have to others as well, because that's where they get their social licence.”

Got a News Tip?

Contact our editor via Proton Mail encrypted, X Direct Message, LinkedIn, or email. You can securely message him on Signal by using his username, Miko Santos.

More on The Evening Post AU

  • Get Evening Post Wrap - for nighly bite size news around Australia and the world.

  • Podwires Daily - for providing news about audio trends and podcasts.

  • Podwires Asia - for reporting on podcasting and audio trends in South East Asia

  • There’s a Glitch - updated tech news and scam and fraud trends

  • The Freeman Chronicle Podcast - features expert interviews on current political and social issues in Australia and worldwide.

  • That Podcast Exchange - This podcast is an insightful conversation with people at the top of their game and deconstructs them to find the tools, tactics, and tricks to help you achieve your dream goal as Podcast Manager.