A rise in shoplifting during Australia's cost-of-living crisis has compelled supermarkets to increase surveillance.

Recently, a large supermarket reported a 20% annual increase in stock loss, which was partially attributed to theft.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics report from June 2023 also revealed a 17% rise in retail theft. As a result, supermarkets claim they have no choice but to tighten security within their facilities in order to lower shoplifting. A major grocery store revealed it would invest more than $40 million in CCTV upgrades, body-worn cameras, and other security measures.

The reaction to increased surveillance has left some Australians worried about privacy, while media reports suggested others feel untrusted and angry. “Nine times out of ten, most shoppers are doing the right thing. A sense of trust is lost when supermarkets increase surveillance in the stores with little explanation,” says consumer behaviour expert, Professor Nitika Garg, School of Marketing at UNSW Business School.  

It’s no secret that supermarkets have been implementing more surveillance to tackle theft. But why are customers reacting negatively towards this? And what should supermarkets be doing to mitigate the negative backlash?  

Why do customers react negatively?  

Many customers have responded negatively to the increased surveillance, with social media platforms such as Reddit and TikTok reflecting a range of disapproval among customers. 

“This is a natural psychological reaction. It happens anytime we feel that our freedom is being limited or curtailed,” says Prof. Garg.  

“The idea that we are not being trusted as consumers is jarring to us because most of us do the right thing anyway. No one likes to be watched. Cameras impinge on our privacy. We as consumers are unsure on how that data is being used. Not having an explanation or little reassurance is adding to the negative reaction.” 

For some consumers, such as those who are more opportunistic and engage in deviant behaviour, the increase in tightened measures might make them more likely to misbehave.  

“This is a consequence of psychological reactance; it pushes people to do the opposite of what they are told. For example, if you see a board saying don't throw stones at it, what do you think you will see? Most likely, it is riddled with dents and holes. The same example can be applied in this setting,” says Prof. Garg. 

Having said that, she says more surveillance in supermarkets will ultimately help reduce shoplifting. “Surveillance will help overall because the minor issues of mis-scanned items will outweigh those showing deviant behaviour. People don’t want to be in an embarrassing situation if they are caught. Most consumers will be more hypervigilant,” she says. 

“People don't have an out right now. Most supermarkets have increased their surveillance. If people don’t want to be filmed by cameras at supermarkets, they have very little choice of where else to go. Consumers will eventually start to look elsewhere.”  

How can supermarkets mitigate negative backlash? 

While supermarkets have been increasing surveillance measures in stores over time, Prof. Garg says the current measures has not been widely explained. 

Supermarkets have had very minimal external communication to tell customers why they are doing this and as a result, Prof. Garg says there is a negative backlash from customers.  

“What the grocery stores are missing out is the opportunity to get consumers on board in this exercise,” she says. 

“Those that have a negative feeling towards supermarkets most likely do not feel as though the supermarket is being fair or loyal to them. This is the reason stores need to step in and make sure they get consumers back on their side.  

“A small campaign explaining to the consumer the impacts of shoplifting will help. The higher amount of shoplifting takes a hit on all consumers as the price of products are increased to account for the stock loss.” 

Prof. Garg also suggested there should be ongoing research in which supermarkets are talking to customers and understanding their concerns. “It is a prime opportunity for research and practice to come together to know how to go forward,” she says. 

Bigger problems to be addressed 

While there is a general correlation between the cost-of-living crisis and increased inflation, there has been a higher number of thefts reported at supermarkets according to a recent report. 

Supermarkets have also noted that while customers pay for their products, many items are mis-scanned at self-checkouts, adding to the increasing percentage of stock loss seen in supermarkets.  

“If increasing numbers of thefts are happening at supermarkets, then a bigger problem needs to be addressed. With customers being more price-conscious from a current cost-of-living crisis, when giant supermarkets post annual super profits, it's hard for consumers not to be frustrated,” says Prof. Garg. 

This comes after giant supermarkets such as Coles and Woolworths have reported profits of $1.1 billion and $1.62 billion respectively from the 2022-2023 financial year.  

“The government should help address this situation. Installing security measures is a temporary fix to a much larger problem,” Prof. Garg concludes. 

Send press releases to [email protected]. Other ways to contact us. Editorially, we may rewrite headlines and descriptions.

Recommend The Freeman Chronicle : Delivered fearless reporting to you

Before you go.. We need your Support

You can get The freeman Chronicle for free right now. Your donation, no matter how big or small, will help us keep doing honest journalism.

At a time when it's almost impossible to find the truth, we bring you news that has been checked for accuracy from reliable sources.

The readers of The Freeman Chronicle are the engine that drives our publication. Add your support to the effort to create a sustainable future for journalism that does not make compromises in the AU.

In the world we live in now, accurate and thorough reporting and analysis are becoming more and more critical. To stop the spread of false information, it's essential that everyone in Australia has access to good reporting.

The Freeman Chronicle contributes to society by opening up access to information and resources for all people, rather than just a select few.

Our only goal is to educate the general public more thoroughly. If you believe in what we're trying to accomplish here, please consider making a contribution right away to ensure our success in the years to come.

Upgrade your subscription to get the most out of it. Join the growing number of people around the world who believe in the power of independent media.

HAVE A TIP ?

Contact me via email, LinkedIn, a Direct Message on X, or my encrypted Proton Mail. In each of those locations, you can ask for my signal.